69 replies to this topic

[Ludono]

Spoiler

Since it seems like we have enough members on Podunk that enjoy anime, and have watched a good amount I thought it'd be a cool idea to make a bracket sort of contest...of sorts. (Grammar FTW?)<br><br>Here's how we'll start, each person will throw out their top 3 shows and once we hit lets say...10 members posting their top 3, or after a couple days. Then we'll tally them up and put them in some sort of bracket arrangement and go from there. Let see how this turns out.<br><br>Top 3 don't need to be in order.<br><br>Mine<br><br>1) Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood<br>2) Clannad<br>3) Code Geass

Round 3 is a go! Get your votes it, this time I just linked the bracket rather than putting a picture.

[Jason Clement]

1) Fullmetal Alchemist
2) Air Gear
3) Gurren Lagann

[SeveranceZero]

1) DBZ
2) Naruto
3) Gundam Wing

[TYLERxDURDEN]

1) Trigun
2) Fullmetal Alchemist
3) Gundam Wing

[DarkCobra86]

Anime so no manga right? We are rating this based on just the anime itself?

[Ludono]

Anime so no manga right? We are rating this based on just the anime itself?

The rules are pretty self explanatory. Your personal top 3 anime.

[Kezins]

High School of the Dead
Witchblade
Full Metal Panic

[barrel]

Seto no Hanayome
Angel Beats
Ruronuni Kenshin (fully aware that it's pure nostalgia, because the second half of the anime is gawd-awful and full of weak-fillers.)

I do have a big soft spot for Trigun... and Gurren Lagann... and Full Metal Panic... and Code Geass... and Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood though, man, picking favs sucks.

[DarkCobra86]

The rules are pretty self explanatory. Your personal top 3 anime.

I just want to make sure. A lot don't count manga, but manga and anime are sometimes counted the same by others. My rank would definitely be different for each one.

anime: school rumble, Read or Die ova, Cowboy Bebop.

[Ludono]

Not sure how many more Podunkers watch anime / post in this forum but we're at 7 people. Could we get one more for good luck?

[DarkCobra86]

Not sure how many more Podunkers watch anime / post in this forum but we're at 7 people. Could we get one more for good luck?

7 is already the lucky number. Just have it when we get 10 so the bracket is big enough.

[InfernoChaos]

ef Tales of Melodies
Clannad
Gurren Lagann

[Jason Clement]

ef Tales of Melodies
Clannad
Gurren Lagann

Yes! Another Gurren Lagann fan!

[TKtheknight]

Man I have so many animes that I really love and enjoy. So here are my personal favorites in my top 10. Not a rank.

1. FMA Brotherhood
2. Code Geass
3. Cowboy Bebop

I picked these because I know I watched them a lot. I could of add DBZ, but I wanted to go different.

[Ludono]

Alright, I'll go with what we got and hopefully we can start the next round soon.

[Ludono]

Time to start the next round! 1 week of voting!

Here are my votes:

Column 1
Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood
Code Geass
Air Gear
DBZ
Evangelion
Fate Stay Night
One Piece
Rurouni Kenshin

Column 2
Clannad
Fullmetal Alchemist
Gurren Lagann
Steins;Gate
Great Teacher Onizuka
Baccano!
Ghost in the Shell
Black Lagoon

[TKtheknight]

Woo! So how do we do this? Is there going to be separate polls or we post on which animes we picked? Exciting competition!

[Ludono]

Woo! So how do we do this? Is there going to be separate polls or we post on which animes we picked? Exciting competition!

Standard bracket breakdown affair. Just follow my example, choose between each pair of games as shown on the bracket in the first post!

[barrel]

1)
Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood
Code Geass
Air Gear
Dragon Ball Z
Trigun
Fate Stay Night (I guess...but the original anime....)
Seto no Hanayome
Rurouni Kenshin

2)
Clannad
Full Metal Alchemist
Gurren Lagann
Steins; Gate
GTO
Baccano!
Angel Beats
School Rumble

[DarkCobra86]

Man are you kidding me with some of these breakdown? Kenshin and champloo round one? FMA and read or die? Ughh this is tough.

btw is there a way you can put brotherhood on column one because I wouldn't have known had I saw your choices.

shoot I wish I remember which one I actually saw between fma and fma brotherhood

here's my pick

column 1
read or die ova
code geass
air gear
dbz
eva
fate stay night
one piece
kenshin

column 2
bebop
fma
gurren lagann
gudam wing
gto
fmp
ghost in the shell
school rumble