49 replies to this topic

[Ludono]

Spoiler

Similar to the tourney thread I started in the anime sub-forum, I'll make one for videogames seeing as this is mainly a videogame site.Here's how we'll start, each person will throw out their top 3 games from this generation. And once we hit lets say...10 members posting their top 3, or after a couple days. Then we'll tally them up and put them in some sort of bracket arrangement and go from there. Let see how this turns out. Top 3 don't need to be in order but need to be from this generation (ie. PS3, 360, Wii etc. PC games anything since 2005 goes)

Mine: Uncharted 2, Mass Effect 2, Metal Gear Solid 4 (Harder than I thought to pick only 3)

ROUND 4 IS A GO!

[TYLERxDURDEN]

Maybe top 3 this generation would give a more consistent and relative field?

[Ludono]

Maybe top 3 this generation would give a more consistent and relative field?

Sure, that would make it slightly easier. Changed OP to match.

[TYLERxDURDEN]

1) Mass Effect 2
2) Uncharted 2
3) Heavy Rain

Runners up: Bioshock, inFAMOUS, Skyrim, and Dead Space

We could have an interesting one for downloadable games too!

[SeveranceZero]

1) Bioshock 1
2) Batman: Arkham City
3) Dead Island (First open world zombie game I really liked)

[Kezins]

1) Bioshock
2) Heavy Rain
3) The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

[DarkCobra86]

Uncharted 2, MGS4 and Batman Arkham Asylum.

[Ludono]

Only 5 people submitting so far? Cmon you can do better!

[bink]

All my favs seem to be on the Gamecube and original xbox. I feel so behind the times, and I haven't played a ton of games so I'll just throw out some I liked out of my teeny tiny repertoire.

Mass effect
Fable II
Rainbow six vegas

*facepalm* SEE? I am so behind. I was even going to put Fable 1 on there and then I was like "Wait a minute...I think that's way older than I'm thinking" and sure enough it was original xbox too. Suck. Man I've got so many games in my backlog now though to play I'm SUPER EXCITED. I just have to find the time.

[Jason Clement]

I'll try and see if I can have the editorial pool submit theirs but I'll have to think on mine just a little longer. When I have three, I'll edit this post to reflect that.

[Shin GenX]

Dark Souls
Portal 2
Braid!!!!

[Marshall Henderson]

This is literally impos--

Metal Gear Solid 3, Pokemon White, Mass Effect 3.

With Disgaea 3 completely in my veins right now, it's hard to leave that off of the list, but I know Disgaea love ebbs and flows.

[TKtheknight]

Ugh so many games to choose from. I'm just going to randomly pick 3 out of the hat.

MGS4
Arkham City
Uncharted 3

I just realized it's all on PS3 when I play 360 more lol.

[Kotomine]

Man this is a tough decision, but here goes:

Borderlands
Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia
Skyrim

[Ludono]

Alright, lets go with what we got, I'll sort everything out and hopefully we can start the next round this week !

[Ludono]

Alright, I had to add a few extras in to fill out the bracket, but the arrangement was completely random. Updated the OP with the bracket, post your picks! I'll probably let this stage run for a week.

Here are my votes:

Column 1
Uncharted 2
Metal Gear Solid 4
Skyrim
Dead Island
Arkham Asylum
Fable 2
Lost Odyssey
Uncharted 3

Column 2
Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect 3
Arkham City
Dead Space
Mass Effect
Super Mario Galaxy
Portal 2
Metal Gear Solid 3 HD

To be fair, Mass Effect 3's ending almost cost it the win against Heavy Rain.

[DarkCobra86]

We should have done ranking, based on which games had the most vote from poster.

My picks are terrible, I haven't even played most of these games to be able to give a full honest answer

column 1
uncharted 2
mgs4
bioshock
infamous
batman aa
gta4
dark souls
uncharted 3

column 2
borderland
heavy rain
batman arkham city
Zelda
mass effect
super mario galaxy
TF2
mgs3

[Ludono]

I'd like to move on to the next round by the end of the week, c'mon guys make your picks!

[TYLERxDURDEN]

Column 1:
Uncharted 2
Metal Gear Solid 4
Skyrim
inFAMOUS
Batman: Arkham Asylum
GTAIV
Dark Souls
Uncharted 3

Column 2:
Mass Effect 2
Heavy Rain
Batman: Arkham City
Dead Space
Mass Effect
Super Mario Galaxy
Portal 2
LittleBigPlanet

Many of my picks are based on which games I played. The only game I picked against because of that was Fallout 3 otherwise I went with what I know.

[Jason Clement]

Column 1

Pokemon White
Metal Gear Solid 4
Skyrim
Infamous
Batman Arkham Asylum
Grand Theft Auto IV
Lost Odyssey
Braid


Column 2

Mass Effect 2
Mass Effect 3
Batman Arkham City
Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
Mass Effect
Super Mario Galaxy
Portal 2
Metal Gear Solid 3